CRITICAL QUESTIONS EXERCISE 1

Assignment: Write a short history of the rise of industrialism in Lowell, Massachusetts, 1820s-1850s, using the primary source documents included with this handout.

Primary Sources: Historians learn about history from primary source documents (i.e., eyewitness accounts of historical events). This critical questions exercise is designed to give you practice working with primary source documents while helping you learn more about one of the most important developments of early nineteenth-century America: the Market Revolution and the rise of industrialism.

For this exercise, you will be examining a variety of primary sources, including: autobiographies and memoirs, letters written by factory workers, travel accounts by foreigners visiting the U.S., government reports, exposes written by social reformers, pictures and songs, contemporary histories, and public relations articles and other documents produced by the manufacturer.

As you use these sources, critically evaluate their strengths and weaknesses as sources. You might think of yourself as an attorney cross-examining a witness (in this situation, the witness is the author of the document). How reliable is the witness? Did the witness actually see the events he is describing or is he just passing along information someone else told him? Does the witness have a bias or personal outlook which might color his understanding of an event? Or, does the witness have a stake in the case which might cause him consciously to slant his testimony? Did the events happen so long ago that the witness' memory may be faulty? Or, are the events so recent that the testimony is colored by the emotions of the moment? If the witness offers physical evidence such as a picture, is it an accurate representation of reality or might it have been staged. Keep in mind that testimony about one aspect of the event may be weaker or stronger than other parts of the testimony. In writing your essay, give greater weight to the reliable testimony (though even a generally unreliable witness may have a thing or two of importance to say)..

Secondary Sources: Historians also learn about history from secondary sources (documents written by other historians based on primary sources). You will want to read Tindall and Shi, America: A Narrative History, 489-492, for background on the factory system at Lowell. However, the point of this exercise is to learn how to use primary sources. I am, therefore, placing some restrictions on your use of secondary sources. You must draw your paper only from the primary source documents included in this handout.

Thesis Statement: Organize your paper around a thesis statement, an argumentative statement you are trying to prove with evidence from primary sources. Somewhere near the beginning of your paper (the first paragraph is usually a good spot), your paper should include a statement which says something like this: "This paper argues that. . . ." Your job in the paper is to present evidence and argument which will prove that your thesis is correct.

Narrowing and Focusing the Topic: Remember, a good history of an event will answer these questions: (1) What happened in the event, when did it happen, and who was involved in the event? (2) What caused the event to happen? (3) What were the consequences of the event?

Many different things may be considered historical events: histories of institutions (such as the factory system at Lowell), economic trends (such as the development of industrialism or the Market Revolution), changes in the status or relations of racial, gender, or economic groups (such as women, farmers, or factory workers), and changes in intellectual concepts (such as concepts of property and labor, right and wrong, freedom and dependency). You may be able to think of other events associated with industrialism in Lowell.

In writing your paper, you may focus on one of these events or survey the whole subject of industrialism in Lowell, as long as you can organize your paper around a thesis statement you are trying to prove with evidence.

Footnotes: Use traditional footnotes (not parenthetical references). Your footnotes may be located either at the bottom of the page or at the end of the paper. If you use a word processor such as Microsoft Word or WordPerfect, putting footnotes at the bottom of the page is very easy. Use the pull-down menus on the menu bar to look for the word: "footnote." Click on that word and your software should guide you through the process with relative ease. (In Microsoft products such as MS Word and MS Works, you can usually find footnotes by clicking on "Insert" on the menu bar and then "Footnote."

For this paper, use a modified version of traditional notes, citing sources by the title of each document and the page number printed on the page. For instance, if your first two notes were citations to the first and the thirty-second page of the handouts, your first two notes would look like this:

      1"Lowell: The New City of Factories," 87.

      2"'Regulations to Be Observed,' Hamilton Manufacturing Company, 1848," 156-157.

If you put your footnotes at the bottom of the page, be sure to separate them from the main text with a line (hit the underline key 20 times).

Length of the Paper: Your paper should be five or fewer pages long (not including footnotes).

Due Date: Your paper is due November 5.


HIS 223: Introduction to American History, 1492-1877

HIS 223: Introduction to American History, 1877-Present

This page was last updated on 9/8/99
| Return to Top of Page | Return to History 223 Supplements | Site Map |
| Study Sheets | Exam 1 | Exam 2 | Exam 3 | Take-home Questions for Exams | Quiz |
| Critical Questions Exercise 1 | Critical Questions Exercise 2 |

Departmental Courses in American History and Civilization:
| AMS 250 | HIS 223 | HIS 225 | HIS 227 | HIS 306 |
| HIS 308 | HIS 310 | HIS 312 | HIS 314 | HIS 318 | HIS 325 |
| HIS 338 | HIS 426 | HIS 430 | HIS 432 | HIS 470 | HIS 475 |

Dr. Harold D. Tallant, Department of History, Georgetown College
400 East College Street, Georgetown, KY 40324, (502) 863-8075
E-mail: htallant@georgetowncollege.edu.

Dr. Tallant's Classes
The American Studies Major
Georgetown College Home Page
Department of History